{ "result": { "cases": { "early": { "code_hash": "bf01176c9ff051efb5f861e9a013aeaf9bf0645ae09baa966e5a0cc7f7a72c14", "experiment_id": 45, "hypothesis_id": 31, "protocol": { "asset_cap": "0.15", "available_delay_minutes": 5, "band": "0", "capacity": "0.001", "capital": "10000", "cohort": [ { "cmc_id": 1, "kraken_symbol": "XBT", "name": "Bitcoin", "symbol": "BTC" }, { "cmc_id": 2, "kraken_symbol": "LTC", "name": "Litecoin", "symbol": "LTC" }, { "cmc_id": 52, "kraken_symbol": "XRP", "name": "XRP", "symbol": "XRP" }, { "cmc_id": 512, "kraken_symbol": "XLM", "name": "Stellar", "symbol": "XLM" }, { "cmc_id": 1027, "kraken_symbol": "ETH", "name": "Ethereum", "symbol": "ETH" }, { "cmc_id": 1214, "kraken_symbol": "LSK", "name": "Lisk", "symbol": "LSK" }, { "cmc_id": 1321, "kraken_symbol": "ETC", "name": "Ethereum Classic", "symbol": "ETC" }, { "cmc_id": 1697, "kraken_symbol": "BAT", "name": "Basic Attention Token", "symbol": "BAT" }, { "cmc_id": 1831, "kraken_symbol": "BCH", "name": "Bitcoin Cash", "symbol": "BCH" }, { "cmc_id": 1975, "kraken_symbol": "LINK", "name": "Chainlink", "symbol": "LINK" }, { "cmc_id": 2010, "kraken_symbol": "ADA", "name": "Cardano", "symbol": "ADA" }, { "cmc_id": 2011, "kraken_symbol": "XTZ", "name": "Tezos", "symbol": "XTZ" } ], "commission": "0.0025", "contributions": "none", "criteria": "Both periods base:profit>0;CAGRdiff>=.02 vs matched_basket and unfiltered;DD<=.40 and matchedDD+.05;730days100reviews. Four stresses:profit>0;CAGRdiff>=0 vs both. Recent paired90day2000seed20261020CI97.5 lower>0 both. Optimistic diagnostic cannot rescue failure.", "dataset_path": "data/research/defensive-20261019/bridge/dataset-bitvavo12.json", "dataset_sha256": "07e8d7a1a741f19bd7a11e232ff75009648375589bd2f58066d2a0132dee7372", "decision_delay_days": 1, "end": "2023-12-31", "exposure": "0.30", "family": "recovery", "ficha_path": "docs/estrategias/historical-recovery-bitvavo-1.md", "ficha_sha256": "20f046f743f0ef97a04aa9132db32fc0b6ff5777c585ec6837677e0827409c8a", "fixed_cost_eur_year": "1200", "half_spread": "0.001", "lookback": 30, "max_order_eur": "1500", "member_count": 12, "min_notional": "5", "min_qty": "0.00000001", "name": "historical_recovery_bitvavo", "periods": { "early": [ "2021-01-01", "2023-12-31" ], "recent": [ "2024-01-01", "2026-09-30" ] }, "provider": "bitvavo", "qty_step": "0.00000001", "scenarios": [ "base", "volume60", "double_cost_half_capacity", "delay_one_more_day", "miss_each_10th", "optimistic_friction_diagnostic" ], "slippage": "0.002", "start": "2021-01-01", "terminal_liquidation": false, "universe_label": "fixed", "version": "1.0.0" }, "reproduced_identically": true, "result_sha256": "e3155c9e3492a9082e6f7e984ab50235a1fe6251039d2c9649463e8696f85bdb", "runs_sha256": { "base": "7354e727e9accdcab0232dbd5b53d5725c6a5f7689960b3f37fbf771a80c476e", "delay_one_more_day": "ffd9ef93162e2d2b638855664de7725995bb6c3f6b0bf3e90cb08d41efb260b7", "double_cost_half_capacity": "138a2cdde50830218353aa91ff8f6b923dd95e630e0db66343afbc5df1e87461", "miss_each_10th": "ab18bfe94220fde0e2e8e65c1adafaac1a7584921caa2b5e023812a7f8180182", "optimistic_friction_diagnostic": "f1b4c5b96173f654a93853eb5224741aae6e3bc88ad31f0a65b4a8dc91a599cf", "volume60": "8d5e9d672ac2600e3aaeccaa05df189a60fc5082e5e7a24cd1afb388a65b5f64" }, "scenarios": { "base": { "books": { "basket30": { "annual_returns": { "2021": 0.559504157476707, "2022": -0.23673403891903178, "2023": 0.23661029241406561 }, "average_exposure": 0.2914208434537481, "cagr": 0.1376362666191262, "costs_eur": 136.4792128441017, "final_eur": 14719.575603972582, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": 1122.0396696810008, "max_drawdown": 0.3399210771399437, "profit_eur": 4719.575603972582, "sharpe": 0.6598198793504679, "trades": 390, "turnover_eur": 24814.40233529122 }, "candidate": { "annual_returns": { "2021": -0.01818887140759362, "2022": -0.1937537745310467, "2023": -0.1757075914637375 }, "average_exposure": 0.07160764909018114, "cagr": -0.13273867249304339, "costs_eur": 6364.614093381493, "final_eur": 6524.946348306447, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -7072.589585985133, "max_drawdown": 0.47613868477609333, "profit_eur": -3475.0536516935526, "sharpe": -1.136860839900993, "trades": 2644, "turnover_eur": 1157202.5624329988 }, "matched_basket": { "annual_returns": { "2021": 0.11773011276440548, "2022": -0.36446060064957664, "2023": -0.16153717944242052 }, "average_exposure": 0.1795714869269225, "cagr": -0.158728127936143, "costs_eur": 6479.762198758226, "final_eur": 5956.117274496726, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -7641.418659794856, "max_drawdown": 0.5540797934201734, "profit_eur": -4043.882725503274, "sharpe": -0.9525706912757456, "trades": 9752, "turnover_eur": 1178138.5815924047 }, "unfiltered": { "annual_returns": { "2021": -0.06526820056645666, "2022": -0.36404014976242527, "2023": -0.23810181821202703 }, "average_exposure": 0.12010217778637396, "cagr": -0.23218012667382504, "costs_eur": 8412.316299641152, "final_eur": 4529.118180980986, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -9068.417753310596, "max_drawdown": 0.6140980705631736, "profit_eur": -5470.881819019014, "sharpe": -1.7213555673483985, "trades": 5260, "turnover_eur": 1529512.0544802092 } }, "decisions": { "executed": 1094 }, "orders": { "capacity_or_minimum": 7274, "filled": 11806, "partial": 6240 } }, "delay_one_more_day": { "books": { "basket30": { "annual_returns": { "2021": 0.5395300205757754, "2022": -0.2400647114754464, "2023": 0.23728696931573467 }, "average_exposure": 0.2905012455039703, "cagr": 0.13131031187572595, "costs_eur": 133.97061417744047, "final_eur": 14475.554642949512, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": 878.0187086579303, "max_drawdown": 0.3443066031265509, "profit_eur": 4475.554642949512, "sharpe": 0.6384181931709714, "trades": 394, "turnover_eur": 24358.29348680736 }, "candidate": { "annual_returns": { "2021": -0.2593678603104761, "2022": -0.233445654702915, "2023": -0.11829200768886494 }, "average_exposure": 0.07873157790946225, "cagr": -0.20612008755511446, "costs_eur": 5634.527402701648, "final_eur": 5005.762973996515, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -8591.772960295066, "max_drawdown": 0.5693699145445186, "profit_eur": -4994.237026003485, "sharpe": -1.6378654919987174, "trades": 2666, "turnover_eur": 1024459.5277639359 }, "matched_basket": { "annual_returns": { "2021": -0.11297468342902217, "2022": -0.39035957957345, "2023": -0.030836262090038646 }, "average_exposure": 0.17841584959665738, "cagr": -0.19387031717071534, "costs_eur": 5568.383165044231, "final_eur": 5240.9126980304745, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -8356.623236261106, "max_drawdown": 0.6215791390530853, "profit_eur": -4759.0873019695255, "sharpe": -1.1262567978740001, "trades": 9545, "turnover_eur": 1012433.3027353147 }, "unfiltered": { "annual_returns": { "2021": -0.25785340573695936, "2022": -0.36756821186623334, "2023": -0.21266641895275196 }, "average_exposure": 0.12418618593673222, "cagr": -0.2825548880514148, "costs_eur": 7599.192145351769, "final_eur": 3695.406044962279, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -9902.129889329302, "max_drawdown": 0.7095375867384439, "profit_eur": -6304.593955037721, "sharpe": -2.0487723905046944, "trades": 5287, "turnover_eur": 1381671.2991548672 } }, "decisions": { "executed": 1093 }, "orders": { "capacity_or_minimum": 7379, "filled": 12059, "partial": 5833 } }, "double_cost_half_capacity": { "books": { "basket30": { "annual_returns": { "2021": 0.4832757609455085, "2022": -0.23594408811181733, "2023": 0.22586545537458336 }, "average_exposure": 0.2819876386160705, "cagr": 0.11591011990286826, "costs_eur": 243.55103947260278, "final_eur": 13892.802027205795, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": 295.26609291421346, "max_drawdown": 0.33999069011192506, "profit_eur": 3892.8020272057947, "sharpe": 0.5904127079759064, "trades": 391, "turnover_eur": 22141.003588418436 }, "candidate": { "annual_returns": { "2021": -0.24332233028370442, "2022": -0.3023189578234119, "2023": -0.2792196852756186 }, "average_exposure": 0.062065919407365666, "cagr": -0.2755176994575558, "costs_eur": 8543.421464047204, "final_eur": 3805.1410243162595, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -9792.394909975323, "max_drawdown": 0.6550083755382343, "profit_eur": -6194.858975683741, "sharpe": -2.8855120600963438, "trades": 2446, "turnover_eur": 776674.6785497458 }, "matched_basket": { "annual_returns": { "2021": -0.12012605031556178, "2022": -0.47063140284789495, "2023": -0.29154018316542485 }, "average_exposure": 0.178805906789181, "cagr": -0.30914322733574784, "costs_eur": 9507.123849158348, "final_eur": 3299.847403972261, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -10297.688530319321, "max_drawdown": 0.7227592861382369, "profit_eur": -6700.1525960277395, "sharpe": -2.174235478797504, "trades": 9406, "turnover_eur": 864283.9862871225 }, "unfiltered": { "annual_returns": { "2021": -0.3792464861399625, "2022": -0.5099175947045611, "2023": -0.44273451178335577 }, "average_exposure": 0.11603587539939038, "cagr": -0.4467677210549269, "costs_eur": 10632.396248421952, "final_eur": 1695.3151589351457, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -11902.220775356436, "max_drawdown": 0.844019893502353, "profit_eur": -8304.684841064854, "sharpe": -4.111942174557153, "trades": 5045, "turnover_eur": 966581.4771292682 } }, "decisions": { "executed": 1094 }, "orders": { "capacity_or_minimum": 8083, "filled": 10855, "partial": 6433 } }, "miss_each_10th": { "books": { "basket30": { "annual_returns": { "2021": 0.5335044834977374, "2022": -0.23110462139617194, "2023": 0.2301889874552585 }, "average_exposure": 0.2904581883618688, "cagr": 0.13208296706054923, "costs_eur": 127.46244097921596, "final_eur": 14505.213837893925, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": 907.677903602344, "max_drawdown": 0.33530346886986107, "profit_eur": 4505.213837893925, "sharpe": 0.6395413482354252, "trades": 357, "turnover_eur": 23174.989268948357 }, "candidate": { "annual_returns": { "2021": 0.03887288044309822, "2022": -0.20070607559187015, "2023": -0.15897094311236526 }, "average_exposure": 0.06898121784048394, "cagr": -0.11286228600645054, "costs_eur": 5732.738089114304, "final_eur": 6983.609091169797, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -6613.926843121784, "max_drawdown": 0.4568513025981553, "profit_eur": -3016.3909088302034, "sharpe": -0.9444865411139606, "trades": 2356, "turnover_eur": 1042316.0162026007 }, "matched_basket": { "annual_returns": { "2021": 0.11202890440769542, "2022": -0.35886384372008306, "2023": -0.10313036567115974 }, "average_exposure": 0.1760629036934741, "cagr": -0.13856823369663962, "costs_eur": 5891.6878362528705, "final_eur": 6394.339121258868, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -7203.196813032713, "max_drawdown": 0.5329763354950263, "profit_eur": -3605.6608787411324, "sharpe": -0.8089180648978344, "trades": 8830, "turnover_eur": 1071215.9702277945 }, "unfiltered": { "annual_returns": { "2021": -0.023307708611509992, "2022": -0.3383827090357109, "2023": -0.20748847658915714 }, "average_exposure": 0.11516114308531777, "cagr": -0.20006068156256862, "costs_eur": 7782.715468554899, "final_eur": 5121.181789256654, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -8476.354145034928, "max_drawdown": 0.588658100085599, "profit_eur": -4878.818210743346, "sharpe": -1.4548281210063483, "trades": 4683, "turnover_eur": 1415039.1761008909 } }, "decisions": { "executed": 985, "missed_scenario": 109 }, "orders": { "capacity_or_minimum": 6603, "filled": 10586, "partial": 5640 } }, "optimistic_friction_diagnostic": { "books": { "basket30": { "annual_returns": { "2021": 0.563026853578811, "2022": -0.2363337313950642, "2023": 0.2377329403286108 }, "average_exposure": 0.29177852967034335, "cagr": 0.13903664621649137, "costs_eur": 87.51864957752265, "final_eur": 14773.96264960374, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": 1176.4267153121586, "max_drawdown": 0.3391881319441866, "profit_eur": 4773.96264960374, "sharpe": 0.664468054847242, "trades": 393, "turnover_eur": 25005.32845072076 }, "candidate": { "annual_returns": { "2021": 0.0995780615939641, "2022": -0.12719822860050134, "2023": -0.11412657907023016 }, "average_exposure": 0.06741320658896877, "cagr": -0.05269820660531921, "costs_eur": 4281.795204848411, "final_eur": 8501.848407715022, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -5095.687526576559, "max_drawdown": 0.3506739421869236, "profit_eur": -1498.1515922849776, "sharpe": -0.4156221616606337, "trades": 2680, "turnover_eur": 1223370.0585281176 }, "matched_basket": { "annual_returns": { "2021": 0.234209724482638, "2022": -0.3069617290878178, "2023": -0.09171393571265218 }, "average_exposure": 0.18008919980169463, "cagr": -0.08075506071834626, "costs_eur": 4547.137782394227, "final_eur": 7769.0663904225985, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -5828.469543868983, "max_drawdown": 0.46481657997335957, "profit_eur": -2230.9336095774015, "sharpe": -0.4226997066579697, "trades": 9982, "turnover_eur": 1299182.2235412074 }, "unfiltered": { "annual_returns": { "2021": 0.09308522092326377, "2022": -0.2651974466130903, "2023": -0.1438939864479335 }, "average_exposure": 0.11386039489875643, "cagr": -0.11743451051643683, "costs_eur": 6089.211596784156, "final_eur": 6876.2590083879895, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -6721.276925903592, "max_drawdown": 0.45271845611596884, "profit_eur": -3123.7409916120105, "sharpe": -0.7986223892040453, "trades": 5305, "turnover_eur": 1739774.7419383302 } }, "decisions": { "executed": 1094 }, "orders": { "capacity_or_minimum": 7002, "filled": 11591, "partial": 6769 } }, "volume60": { "books": { "basket30": { "annual_returns": { "2021": 0.559504157476707, "2022": -0.23673403891903178, "2023": 0.23661029241406561 }, "average_exposure": 0.2914208434537481, "cagr": 0.1376362666191262, "costs_eur": 136.4792128441017, "final_eur": 14719.575603972582, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": 1122.0396696810008, "max_drawdown": 0.3399210771399437, "profit_eur": 4719.575603972582, "sharpe": 0.6598198793504679, "trades": 390, "turnover_eur": 24814.40233529122 }, "candidate": { "annual_returns": { "2021": -0.07719391810857545, "2022": -0.16412487692644961, "2023": -0.19262884545890624 }, "average_exposure": 0.07080254372106871, "cagr": -0.1461241420704762, "costs_eur": 6084.345214570946, "final_eur": 6227.6626264564175, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -7369.873307835163, "max_drawdown": 0.4667706304613862, "profit_eur": -3772.3373735435825, "sharpe": -1.325238173762017, "trades": 2602, "turnover_eur": 1106244.5844674448 }, "matched_basket": { "annual_returns": { "2021": 0.15364474326454847, "2022": -0.3751512484688724, "2023": -0.15526524508480366 }, "average_exposure": 0.17812651461301285, "cagr": -0.1524995554511105, "costs_eur": 6556.0210537567, "final_eur": 6089.299856789286, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -7508.236077502295, "max_drawdown": 0.5419246886032263, "profit_eur": -3910.7001432107136, "sharpe": -0.9042160842736384, "trades": 9642, "turnover_eur": 1192003.8279557636 }, "unfiltered": { "annual_returns": { "2021": -0.017734210461819555, "2022": -0.363125566465229, "2023": -0.2197934946989486 }, "average_exposure": 0.11711947017218802, "cagr": -0.21278563010618057, "costs_eur": 8569.457077615252, "final_eur": 4880.815608480004, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -8716.720325811577, "max_drawdown": 0.5839581666243605, "profit_eur": -5119.184391519996, "sharpe": -1.5512270780431385, "trades": 5201, "turnover_eur": 1558083.1050209547 } }, "decisions": { "executed": 1094 }, "orders": { "capacity_or_minimum": 7397, "filled": 11694, "partial": 6141 } } }, "uncertainty": { "block_days": 90, "comparisons": { "matched_basket": { "lower": -0.11678072285300742, "upper": 0.17483988780786183 }, "unfiltered": { "lower": 0.03690482242988312, "upper": 0.20626544867211882 } }, "confidence": 0.975, "global_multiple_testing_adjustment": false, "local_comparison_count": 2, "metric": "annualized_log_growth_difference", "samples": 2000, "seed": 20261020 }, "verdict": { "automatic_promotion": false, "economic_failures": [ "base:positive_profit", "base:drawdown_below40pct", "volume60:positive_profit", "double_cost_half_capacity:positive_profit", "delay_one_more_day:positive_profit", "delay_one_more_day:matched_basket_excess", "miss_each_10th:positive_profit" ], "outcome": "negative", "statistical_screen_passed": false, "sufficient_sample": true } }, "recent": { "code_hash": "bf01176c9ff051efb5f861e9a013aeaf9bf0645ae09baa966e5a0cc7f7a72c14", "experiment_id": 45, "hypothesis_id": 31, "protocol": { "asset_cap": "0.15", "available_delay_minutes": 5, "band": "0", "capacity": "0.001", "capital": "10000", "cohort": [ { "cmc_id": 1, "kraken_symbol": "XBT", "name": "Bitcoin", "symbol": "BTC" }, { "cmc_id": 2, "kraken_symbol": "LTC", "name": "Litecoin", "symbol": "LTC" }, { "cmc_id": 52, "kraken_symbol": "XRP", "name": "XRP", "symbol": "XRP" }, { "cmc_id": 512, "kraken_symbol": "XLM", "name": "Stellar", "symbol": "XLM" }, { "cmc_id": 1027, "kraken_symbol": "ETH", "name": "Ethereum", "symbol": "ETH" }, { "cmc_id": 1214, "kraken_symbol": "LSK", "name": "Lisk", "symbol": "LSK" }, { "cmc_id": 1321, "kraken_symbol": "ETC", "name": "Ethereum Classic", "symbol": "ETC" }, { "cmc_id": 1697, "kraken_symbol": "BAT", "name": "Basic Attention Token", "symbol": "BAT" }, { "cmc_id": 1831, "kraken_symbol": "BCH", "name": "Bitcoin Cash", "symbol": "BCH" }, { "cmc_id": 1975, "kraken_symbol": "LINK", "name": "Chainlink", "symbol": "LINK" }, { "cmc_id": 2010, "kraken_symbol": "ADA", "name": "Cardano", "symbol": "ADA" }, { "cmc_id": 2011, "kraken_symbol": "XTZ", "name": "Tezos", "symbol": "XTZ" } ], "commission": "0.0025", "contributions": "none", "criteria": "Both periods base:profit>0;CAGRdiff>=.02 vs matched_basket and unfiltered;DD<=.40 and matchedDD+.05;730days100reviews. Four stresses:profit>0;CAGRdiff>=0 vs both. Recent paired90day2000seed20261020CI97.5 lower>0 both. Optimistic diagnostic cannot rescue failure.", "dataset_path": "data/research/defensive-20261019/bridge/dataset-bitvavo12.json", "dataset_sha256": "07e8d7a1a741f19bd7a11e232ff75009648375589bd2f58066d2a0132dee7372", "decision_delay_days": 1, "end": "2026-09-30", "exposure": "0.30", "family": "recovery", "ficha_path": "docs/estrategias/historical-recovery-bitvavo-1.md", "ficha_sha256": "20f046f743f0ef97a04aa9132db32fc0b6ff5777c585ec6837677e0827409c8a", "fixed_cost_eur_year": "1200", "half_spread": "0.001", "lookback": 30, "max_order_eur": "1500", "member_count": 12, "min_notional": "5", "min_qty": "0.00000001", "name": "historical_recovery_bitvavo", "periods": { "early": [ "2021-01-01", "2023-12-31" ], "recent": [ "2024-01-01", "2026-09-30" ] }, "provider": "bitvavo", "qty_step": "0.00000001", "scenarios": [ "base", "volume60", "double_cost_half_capacity", "delay_one_more_day", "miss_each_10th", "optimistic_friction_diagnostic" ], "slippage": "0.002", "start": "2024-01-01", "terminal_liquidation": false, "universe_label": "fixed", "version": "1.0.0" }, "reproduced_identically": true, "result_sha256": "9955597a155fbf40a79c21f4dab7a7b84312e99f2c29cd50ef56098040a41100", "runs_sha256": { "base": "1eaafef3839e1a23a6379fe14a48c7dc45bd59dce6d696a1812e148690566ee4", "delay_one_more_day": "53f8cac8b72fbd209d1cc6cfdb846bfd72634cf229acadec9f4b997f1b707069", "double_cost_half_capacity": "b29ead0a6b53e9415bfcb98ed74e9134c8e11ce0587f78f15ba6adf88dfa44fd", "miss_each_10th": "364628db8a6d030ebddf87d5af85d3269133ff255f771cf81f055ffd7f437791", "optimistic_friction_diagnostic": "4701a55fe50f1c66c365482554b156cdf560885d6bde4c834883dacbf1a86b56", "volume60": "ddca0124ebee13a5f18e5bc3e8e846853f5dfe2c137272dd89b0b5a56517182f" }, "scenarios": { "base": { "books": { "basket30": { "annual_returns": { "2024": 0.33253428006718977, "2025": -0.09960411729341634, "2026": 0.007579165318946979 }, "average_exposure": 0.2758175137745261, "cagr": 0.07145378724795504, "costs_eur": 86.66496665351701, "final_eur": 12089.019253959388, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -1209.5433743773674, "max_drawdown": 0.2887493540956274, "profit_eur": 2089.019253959388, "sharpe": 0.44093600687715995, "trades": 331, "turnover_eur": 15757.266664275821 }, "candidate": { "annual_returns": { "2024": -0.1852447011992303, "2025": -0.20083397264208291, "2026": -0.13410300235095707 }, "average_exposure": 0.07058891209203458, "cagr": -0.18817477150633977, "costs_eur": 4647.192628141954, "final_eur": 5638.069708057193, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -7660.492920279563, "max_drawdown": 0.45416208749087117, "profit_eur": -4361.930291942807, "sharpe": -2.7017259195795407, "trades": 2184, "turnover_eur": 844944.114207628 }, "matched_basket": { "annual_returns": { "2024": -0.18821858003331837, "2025": -0.19402801793717073, "2026": -0.1293953417729682 }, "average_exposure": 0.18421276032937292, "cagr": -0.185143219255682, "costs_eur": 4206.675486962626, "final_eur": 5696.131912461014, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -7602.430715875742, "max_drawdown": 0.49902312969567986, "profit_eur": -4303.868087538986, "sharpe": -1.5645822209992302, "trades": 8359, "turnover_eur": 764850.0885386592 }, "unfiltered": { "annual_returns": { "2024": -0.2979847469468051, "2025": -0.25279041131448354, "2026": -0.2395019927762676 }, "average_exposure": 0.11679499451953403, "cagr": -0.28417842919090863, "costs_eur": 6052.498024132421, "final_eur": 3989.211525968883, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -9309.351102367873, "max_drawdown": 0.6086406747174594, "profit_eur": -6010.7884740311165, "sharpe": -3.5235034295190157, "trades": 4667, "turnover_eur": 1100454.1862058947 } }, "decisions": { "executed": 1003 }, "orders": { "capacity_or_minimum": 7945, "filled": 10091, "partial": 5450 } }, "delay_one_more_day": { "books": { "basket30": { "annual_returns": { "2024": 0.3405702193993563, "2025": -0.10218735196496609, "2026": 0.0030577867383660973 }, "average_exposure": 0.27884427792505323, "cagr": 0.07092453290374023, "costs_eur": 87.84600225368095, "final_eur": 12072.611922659971, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -1225.9507056767843, "max_drawdown": 0.29050673741954225, "profit_eur": 2072.6119226599712, "sharpe": 0.43970260426752894, "trades": 333, "turnover_eur": 15972.000409760172 }, "candidate": { "annual_returns": { "2024": -0.1968351060383301, "2025": -0.0811577975660791, "2026": -0.16433693748472555 }, "average_exposure": 0.06855510598516928, "cagr": -0.16125286817516138, "costs_eur": 4722.7014247421, "final_eur": 6167.041311398563, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -7131.521316938192, "max_drawdown": 0.38329586886014366, "profit_eur": -3832.9586886014367, "sharpe": -2.2268008596571476, "trades": 2218, "turnover_eur": 858672.9863167454 }, "matched_basket": { "annual_returns": { "2024": -0.1976829950516753, "2025": -0.1458801047239887, "2026": -0.029437324801079412 }, "average_exposure": 0.18664370921440832, "cagr": -0.13787999087742542, "costs_eur": 4253.590702327085, "final_eur": 6651.022559571005, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -6647.54006876575, "max_drawdown": 0.4335073044427542, "profit_eur": -3348.9774404289947, "sharpe": -1.0552008949746166, "trades": 8246, "turnover_eur": 773380.1276958336 }, "unfiltered": { "annual_returns": { "2024": -0.2838707365539145, "2025": -0.22112089185346429, "2026": -0.1861066405948003 }, "average_exposure": 0.11491969968153648, "cagr": -0.2497104121555277, "costs_eur": 6118.961789635604, "final_eur": 4539.719095421455, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -8758.8435329153, "max_drawdown": 0.5460280904578545, "profit_eur": -5460.280904578545, "sharpe": -2.8562653955308153, "trades": 4695, "turnover_eur": 1112538.5072064735 } }, "decisions": { "executed": 1002 }, "orders": { "capacity_or_minimum": 7798, "filled": 9988, "partial": 5504 } }, "double_cost_half_capacity": { "books": { "basket30": { "annual_returns": { "2024": 0.31924140905949794, "2025": -0.09494308887604108, "2026": -0.0008066013037456576 }, "average_exposure": 0.25716995031196366, "cagr": 0.06631316489094008, "costs_eur": 162.44052573386858, "final_eur": 11930.254819853217, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -1368.3078084835388, "max_drawdown": 0.270316972132124, "profit_eur": 1930.2548198532168, "sharpe": 0.448277387455571, "trades": 318, "turnover_eur": 14767.32052126078 }, "candidate": { "annual_returns": { "2024": -0.27830378880385587, "2025": -0.32422885975917504, "2026": -0.24714302657014497 }, "average_exposure": 0.06022363877145936, "cagr": -0.30545449944142444, "costs_eur": 6486.091515755705, "final_eur": 3671.694538065386, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -9626.86809027137, "max_drawdown": 0.63923187748328, "profit_eur": -6328.305461934614, "sharpe": -5.137733009540013, "trades": 1943, "turnover_eur": 589644.6832505186 }, "matched_basket": { "annual_returns": { "2024": -0.3158011923642161, "2025": -0.3173277516451307, "2026": -0.2365083643431457 }, "average_exposure": 0.18209993976109495, "cagr": -0.3127855874639822, "costs_eur": 6443.2266870252215, "final_eur": 3566.143746682996, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -9732.41888165376, "max_drawdown": 0.662806470539734, "profit_eur": -6433.856253317004, "sharpe": -2.9523121058833475, "trades": 7743, "turnover_eur": 585747.8806386566 }, "unfiltered": { "annual_returns": { "2024": -0.44798811647871306, "2025": -0.4571383016821128, "2026": -0.39647259964175763 }, "average_exposure": 0.11022130944407234, "cagr": -0.4631880423571523, "costs_eur": 8284.729133762456, "final_eur": 1808.5670748677123, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -11489.995553469043, "max_drawdown": 0.819315486881634, "profit_eur": -8191.432925132288, "sharpe": -6.782245079401352, "trades": 4312, "turnover_eur": 753157.193978405 } }, "decisions": { "executed": 1003 }, "orders": { "capacity_or_minimum": 9358, "filled": 9195, "partial": 5121 } }, "miss_each_10th": { "books": { "basket30": { "annual_returns": { "2024": 0.33253428006718977, "2025": -0.10300103633590674, "2026": 0.008153058514044798 }, "average_exposure": 0.2762708500063869, "cagr": 0.07020313202553807, "costs_eur": 83.51255021578257, "final_eur": 12050.270712799065, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -1248.2919155376903, "max_drawdown": 0.2908271050842285, "profit_eur": 2050.270712799065, "sharpe": 0.434802472775675, "trades": 313, "turnover_eur": 15184.100039233195 }, "candidate": { "annual_returns": { "2024": -0.1864782751842753, "2025": -0.16655429036944347, "2026": -0.11591549183786176 }, "average_exposure": 0.0703005073019242, "cagr": -0.16987583879237944, "costs_eur": 4214.533957506491, "final_eur": 5994.32451802505, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -7304.238110311706, "max_drawdown": 0.42364411384690603, "profit_eur": -4005.6754819749503, "sharpe": -2.3849825159521854, "trades": 1958, "turnover_eur": 766278.9013648165 }, "matched_basket": { "annual_returns": { "2024": -0.22006730368673433, "2025": -0.17907512290568806, "2026": -0.11978499112548191 }, "average_exposure": 0.18365785770696239, "cagr": -0.1882979363135564, "costs_eur": 3648.93453770065, "final_eur": 5635.718774241856, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -7662.843854094899, "max_drawdown": 0.5052040341695312, "profit_eur": -4364.281225758144, "sharpe": -1.5734546748312426, "trades": 7419, "turnover_eur": 663442.6432183 }, "unfiltered": { "annual_returns": { "2024": -0.31167091689305215, "2025": -0.23488364788066174, "2026": -0.2157817787833819 }, "average_exposure": 0.11509585565390895, "cagr": -0.2750827559328669, "costs_eur": 5315.522008334306, "final_eur": 4130.099669101899, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -9168.462959234857, "max_drawdown": 0.5956105622493859, "profit_eur": -5869.900330898101, "sharpe": -3.291291235922217, "trades": 4171, "turnover_eur": 966458.5469698737 } }, "decisions": { "executed": 903, "missed_scenario": 100 }, "orders": { "capacity_or_minimum": 7177, "filled": 8980, "partial": 4881 } }, "optimistic_friction_diagnostic": { "books": { "basket30": { "annual_returns": { "2024": 0.33473140167549076, "2025": -0.0989948402155344, "2026": 0.007928543447411007 }, "average_exposure": 0.27596675229863155, "cagr": 0.07249526820124719, "costs_eur": 55.33412150283348, "final_eur": 12121.347452331001, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -1177.215176005754, "max_drawdown": 0.28807212215790956, "profit_eur": 2121.3474523310015, "sharpe": 0.44557175295146256, "trades": 332, "turnover_eur": 15809.749000809566 }, "candidate": { "annual_returns": { "2024": -0.12190514733255586, "2025": -0.12427886586178027, "2026": -0.07794928680955404 }, "average_exposure": 0.06842379024818296, "cagr": -0.11758753439771519, "costs_eur": 3182.3495767207382, "final_eur": 7090.258518090501, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -6208.304110246255, "max_drawdown": 0.31469626529218886, "profit_eur": -2909.7414819094993, "sharpe": -1.670031498172427, "trades": 2189, "turnover_eur": 909242.7362059251 }, "matched_basket": { "annual_returns": { "2024": -0.12496165544672622, "2025": -0.12982516974224578, "2026": -0.07748877174881907 }, "average_exposure": 0.1843022891752266, "cagr": -0.12058111226290624, "costs_eur": 2917.8504747184234, "final_eur": 7024.335759612861, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -6274.226868723895, "max_drawdown": 0.40156120185725064, "profit_eur": -2975.664240387139, "sharpe": -0.9613563257505199, "trades": 8493, "turnover_eur": 833671.5642052639 }, "unfiltered": { "annual_returns": { "2024": -0.208971551980775, "2025": -0.14197913497525028, "2026": -0.15395400920242464 }, "average_exposure": 0.11370590259187897, "cagr": -0.1827480245104678, "costs_eur": 4385.597322595831, "final_eur": 5742.27415415579, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -7556.288474180966, "max_drawdown": 0.44128812322511257, "profit_eur": -4257.72584584421, "sharpe": -2.151889936192848, "trades": 4698, "turnover_eur": 1253027.8064559519 } }, "decisions": { "executed": 1003 }, "orders": { "capacity_or_minimum": 7814, "filled": 10075, "partial": 5637 } }, "volume60": { "books": { "basket30": { "annual_returns": { "2024": 0.33253428006718977, "2025": -0.09960411729341634, "2026": 0.007579165318946979 }, "average_exposure": 0.2758175137745261, "cagr": 0.07145378724795504, "costs_eur": 86.66496665351701, "final_eur": 12089.019253959388, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -1209.5433743773674, "max_drawdown": 0.2887493540956274, "profit_eur": 2089.019253959388, "sharpe": 0.44093600687715995, "trades": 331, "turnover_eur": 15757.266664275821 }, "candidate": { "annual_returns": { "2024": -0.20101243156193482, "2025": -0.15990568597101473, "2026": -0.14494501643005864 }, "average_exposure": 0.06601506141925516, "cagr": -0.1828998607129524, "costs_eur": 4408.218654874323, "final_eur": 5739.342071490498, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -7559.220556846258, "max_drawdown": 0.43264520213613, "profit_eur": -4260.657928509502, "sharpe": -2.7349890799220415, "trades": 2171, "turnover_eur": 801494.3008862406 }, "matched_basket": { "annual_returns": { "2024": -0.23692519947586166, "2025": -0.22339715858392606, "2026": -0.15176240432604238 }, "average_exposure": 0.18659603525221033, "cagr": -0.22137467990065096, "costs_eur": 3917.503097204102, "final_eur": 5026.707380742553, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -8271.855247594202, "max_drawdown": 0.5407703834572569, "profit_eur": -4973.292619257447, "sharpe": -1.9403451956864952, "trades": 8143, "turnover_eur": 712273.2904007457 }, "unfiltered": { "annual_returns": { "2024": -0.3162372633533902, "2025": -0.28302224041237223, "2026": -0.23978270287536596 }, "average_exposure": 0.11810478422795448, "cagr": -0.30167283666050837, "costs_eur": 5827.014229146863, "final_eur": 3726.9096133155012, "fixed_cost_sensitivity_profit_eur": -9571.653015021253, "max_drawdown": 0.6315360081419967, "profit_eur": -6273.090386684498, "sharpe": -3.7599967364464226, "trades": 4682, "turnover_eur": 1059457.1325721568 } }, "decisions": { "executed": 1003 }, "orders": { "capacity_or_minimum": 8304, "filled": 9992, "partial": 5335 } } }, "uncertainty": { "block_days": 90, "comparisons": { "matched_basket": { "lower": -0.1498635933296848, "upper": 0.15627436713941179 }, "unfiltered": { "lower": 0.058752194426296464, "upper": 0.20116230920471073 } }, "confidence": 0.975, "global_multiple_testing_adjustment": false, "local_comparison_count": 2, "metric": "annualized_log_growth_difference", "samples": 2000, "seed": 20261020 }, "verdict": { "automatic_promotion": false, "economic_failures": [ "base:positive_profit", "base:matched_basket_excess", "base:drawdown_below40pct", "volume60:positive_profit", "double_cost_half_capacity:positive_profit", "delay_one_more_day:positive_profit", "delay_one_more_day:matched_basket_excess", "miss_each_10th:positive_profit" ], "outcome": "negative", "statistical_screen_passed": false, "sufficient_sample": true } } }, "experiment_id": 45, "hypothesis_id": 31, "protocol": { "asset_cap": "0.15", "available_delay_minutes": 5, "band": "0", "capacity": "0.001", "capital": "10000", "cohort": [ { "cmc_id": 1, "kraken_symbol": "XBT", "name": "Bitcoin", "symbol": "BTC" }, { "cmc_id": 2, "kraken_symbol": "LTC", "name": "Litecoin", "symbol": "LTC" }, { "cmc_id": 52, "kraken_symbol": "XRP", "name": "XRP", "symbol": "XRP" }, { "cmc_id": 512, "kraken_symbol": "XLM", "name": "Stellar", "symbol": "XLM" }, { "cmc_id": 1027, "kraken_symbol": "ETH", "name": "Ethereum", "symbol": "ETH" }, { "cmc_id": 1214, "kraken_symbol": "LSK", "name": "Lisk", "symbol": "LSK" }, { "cmc_id": 1321, "kraken_symbol": "ETC", "name": "Ethereum Classic", "symbol": "ETC" }, { "cmc_id": 1697, "kraken_symbol": "BAT", "name": "Basic Attention Token", "symbol": "BAT" }, { "cmc_id": 1831, "kraken_symbol": "BCH", "name": "Bitcoin Cash", "symbol": "BCH" }, { "cmc_id": 1975, "kraken_symbol": "LINK", "name": "Chainlink", "symbol": "LINK" }, { "cmc_id": 2010, "kraken_symbol": "ADA", "name": "Cardano", "symbol": "ADA" }, { "cmc_id": 2011, "kraken_symbol": "XTZ", "name": "Tezos", "symbol": "XTZ" } ], "commission": "0.0025", "contributions": "none", "criteria": "Both periods base:profit>0;CAGRdiff>=.02 vs matched_basket and unfiltered;DD<=.40 and matchedDD+.05;730days100reviews. Four stresses:profit>0;CAGRdiff>=0 vs both. Recent paired90day2000seed20261020CI97.5 lower>0 both. Optimistic diagnostic cannot rescue failure.", "dataset_path": "data/research/defensive-20261019/bridge/dataset-bitvavo12.json", "dataset_sha256": "07e8d7a1a741f19bd7a11e232ff75009648375589bd2f58066d2a0132dee7372", "decision_delay_days": 1, "end": "2026-09-30", "exposure": "0.30", "family": "recovery", "ficha_path": "docs/estrategias/historical-recovery-bitvavo-1.md", "ficha_sha256": "20f046f743f0ef97a04aa9132db32fc0b6ff5777c585ec6837677e0827409c8a", "fixed_cost_eur_year": "1200", "half_spread": "0.001", "lookback": 30, "max_order_eur": "1500", "member_count": 12, "min_notional": "5", "min_qty": "0.00000001", "name": "historical_recovery_bitvavo", "periods": { "early": [ "2021-01-01", "2023-12-31" ], "recent": [ "2024-01-01", "2026-09-30" ] }, "provider": "bitvavo", "qty_step": "0.00000001", "scenarios": [ "base", "volume60", "double_cost_half_capacity", "delay_one_more_day", "miss_each_10th", "optimistic_friction_diagnostic" ], "slippage": "0.002", "start": "2021-01-01", "terminal_liquidation": false, "universe_label": "fixed", "version": "1.0.0" }, "result_sha256": "29f038f6a89f4eb34310c7a4d10ec776eec7d93fcde3c8177221966ba55dbf62", "verdict": { "automatic_promotion": false, "economic_failures": { "early": [ "base:positive_profit", "base:drawdown_below40pct", "volume60:positive_profit", "double_cost_half_capacity:positive_profit", "delay_one_more_day:positive_profit", "delay_one_more_day:matched_basket_excess", "miss_each_10th:positive_profit" ], "recent": [ "base:positive_profit", "base:matched_basket_excess", "base:drawdown_below40pct", "volume60:positive_profit", "double_cost_half_capacity:positive_profit", "delay_one_more_day:positive_profit", "delay_one_more_day:matched_basket_excess", "miss_each_10th:positive_profit" ] }, "outcome": "negative" } }, "validation": { "frozen_files_unchanged": 211, "reproduced_scenarios": 12, "reconciliation": { "early": { "books": 24, "daily_valuations": 26280, "trades": 105647 }, "recent": { "books": 24, "daily_valuations": 24096, "trades": 90249 } }, "diagnostics": { "early": { "invalid_signal_days": 0, "selection_count": { "2": 552, "1": 191, "0": 351 }, "candidate_orders": { "partial": 1543, "filled": 1101, "capacity_or_minimum": 670 } }, "recent": { "invalid_signal_days": 0, "selection_count": { "2": 526, "0": 291, "1": 186 }, "candidate_orders": { "partial": 1149, "filled": 1035, "capacity_or_minimum": 1032 } } }, "full_suite_passed": 384, "ruff_passed": true, "postgresql": "17, disposable UTC test database, migration tests included", "production_readonly_counts": { "hypotheses": 31, "experiments": 45, "trade_orders": 0, "order_intents": 0 } } }